Mastering the Art of Communicating Bad News to Clients
Bad news is never easy to deliver—especially when it’s to your clients.
Bad case outcomes, surprise delays, or missed mistakes—stuff happens. But how you spin the tough news can make or break your professional relationships.
For small law firms and entrepreneurial attorneys, bad news isn’t just a conversation. It’s an opportunity to build trust, showcase professionalism, and solidify client loyalty.
If you’re wondering how to approach challenging conversations, you’ve come to the right place. This guide provides actionable strategies for delivering bad news with clarity, empathy, and professionalism. Stick with us, and you’ll soon be turning “uh-oh” moments into “aha!” trust-building wins.
Understanding your client’s perspective
Before delivering bad news, take a moment to step into your client’s shoes. Think about how the information affects them—not just the practical implications, but the emotional ones too. Are they likely to feel disappointed? Angry? Anxious about their case? Understanding their perspective helps you approach the conversation with empathy and tailor your delivery to their emotional state.
Why it matters:
Your clients aren’t just numbers on a docket. They’re people who have trusted you to handle something significant in their lives. Recognizing their expectations and potential reactions creates a sense of care that sets you apart as their trusted advocate.
Quick tips:
- Review past interactions to understand your client’s communication style and preferences.
- Anticipate questions they’re likely to ask, such as “What caused this?” or “What happens next?”
- Keep their values and priorities at the forefront of your communication
When you demonstrate that you’ve considered their unique situation, you’re already building a foundation of trust—no matter the news you have to share.
Choosing the right medium
Delivering news is as much about how you communicate as it is about what you say. Selecting the right communication channel is crucial for ensuring your message is well-received.
- Phone calls: Ideal for delivering sensitive or complex news when immediate dialogue is necessary.
- In-person meetings: Best for major updates or bad news that involves strategic planning. Being face-to-face helps establish rapport and makes it easier to read the client’s emotions.
- Email: Appropriate for less sensitive updates or when providing detailed written context. Use this medium if you want the client to review specific documents or instructions.
Pro tip: If you start with an email, follow up with a phone call to invite further discussion. This two-pronged approach ensures that clients feel supported.
Imagine this difference:
- Cold and abrupt email-only delivery says, “This isn’t my priority.”
- A well-timed call or meeting says, “This matters to both of us, and I’m here to address it.”
It only takes a moment to choose the right medium—but the long-term benefits to your client relationships are priceless.
Drafting the message
Crafting the perfect message is part art, part strategy. When you’re dealing with bad news, clarity, empathy, and professionalism are your trifecta of success.
What to include:
- A Clear, Direct Statement of the Situation: Don’t beat around the bush—clients appreciate honesty and transparency. For example, instead of saying, “This development may not be ideal,” say, “Unfortunately, the court denied this motion.”
- Empathy and Understanding: Acknowledge the client’s potential emotions. Simple phrases like, “I understand this may be disappointing,” go a long way.
- Reasonable Context: Explain how and why the situation occurred without excuses or unnecessary legal jargon. This shows you respect their intelligence and need for clarity.
- Proposed Solutions or Next Steps: Reassure them by focusing on solutions. For instance, “While this was not the outcome we hoped for, here’s what I recommend as our next move.”
Draft example:
Subject Line (if email): Your Case Update – Important Information Inside
“Hi [Client Name],
I want to update you on a recent development regarding [case specifics]. Unfortunately, [state issue concisely]. I completely understand how this might feel, and I’d like to reassure you that I’ve already begun considering our next steps. Here’s how we’ll move forward [outline solutions]. Please feel free to call me directly if you have any questions or concerns about this update.”
Pro tip:
Neutralize overly negative language. Instead of “This is an unfortunate mistake,” try “This is an unforeseen challenge we are actively addressing.”
Empathy + professionalism = a winning formula.
Preparing for and handling the conversation
The moments before delivering bad news are critical. Preparation ensures that the conversation runs as smoothly as possible, even when emotions are high.
Checklist before the conversation:
- Practice Your Delivery: When delivering difficult news verbally, role-play with a colleague to anticipate tricky questions or potential client reactions.
- Have Answers in Hand: Bring any documentation, timelines, or evidence to back up your statements.
- Stay in Control of Your Tone: Bad news doesn’t have to equal bad energy. Stay calm, compassionate, and confident.
During the conversation:
- Acknowledge Their Reactions: Statements like “I can understand why this is upsetting” validate their feelings without assigning blame.
- Be Patient: Give the client ample time to process and respond before moving on to solutions.
- Stick to Facts: While it’s important to be understanding, focus on delivering actionable insights rather than apologizing excessively.
With preparation and poise, even the hardest conversations can leave clients consistently assured of your professionalism.
Following up
Think the tough part is over? Think again. Post-communication follow-ups show clients that you’re committed to guiding them through the process long after delivering the initial update.
Why follow-up matters:
- Reinforces trust and accountability.
- Provides an opportunity to answer additional questions or concerns.
- Strengthens long-term client relationships by showing genuine care.
How to follow up:
- Send a Recap Email: Detail any next steps discussed during your conversation and ensure there’s a clear action plan in place. Include a sentence like, “Please don’t hesitate to contact me if you have further concerns.”
- Schedule a Check-In: Reach out a week or two later. Whether it’s a quick phone call or a progress update email, staying in touch demonstrates ongoing support.
Think of follow-ups as handling loose threads to weave a stronger client relationship.
Build trust, even in tough situations
Delivering bad news to clients isn’t just about damage control—it’s an opportunity to sharpen your communication skills, strengthen trust, and prove your resilience as a professional. By stepping into your client’s shoes, choosing the right medium, drafting clear and empathetic messages, and following through with consistency, you’re showing clients that you’re the steady anchor they can rely on—even in stormy seas.
Want to learn more actionable strategies for leveling up your legal practice?
Subscribe to our blog and get empowering insights delivered directly to your inbox! After all, even the toughest attorneys can use a little backup.