Managing a small law firm or solo practice can feel like a constant balancing act—juggling client cases, court deadlines, and endless administrative work. With only so many hours in the day, staying on top of everything can be overwhelming.
That’s where legal staffing comes in. Whether you’re considering an in-house hire or a virtual legal assistant, finding the right support can transform your workflow and help your firm grow.
In this blog, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both options, covering key factors like cost, flexibility, and scalability, so you can decide what’s best for your practice.
What’s the difference between a virtual legal assistant and an in-house staff member?
First, let’s clarify the roles so we’re all on the same page.
-
Virtual Legal Assistants
Virtual Legal Assistants are specialized remote professionals trained to assist law firms. They provide support with tasks such as client communication, document preparation, case research, client communications, and appointment scheduling. Most Virtual Legal Assistants are hired through virtual staffing companies (like Back Office Betties) or as independent contractors, so there’s no need to worry about traditional employee benefits or office overhead. They’re perfect for attorneys who want to maximize return on staffing investment without sacrificing expert help.
-
In-house staff
An in-house staff member sits right under your roof (or in your office space). They perform standard administrative duties, along with more hands-on tasks such as managing physical client records or greeting clients in person. This category includes paralegals, receptionists, and legal secretaries who become an integral part of your team both physically and strategically.
Now that we’ve drawn the lines, let’s compare them in the areas that matter most.
Cost analysis: A tale of two budgets
When deciding between a Virtual Legal Assistant and an in-house hire, costs are often the driving force. Here’s a breakdown of what you’re looking at for each.
Virtual Legal Assistant
- No overhead: Virtual Legal Assistants work remotely, so no desk, computer, or coffee refills to provide.
- Pay-as-you-go: Many virtual staffing services allow pay-per-hour or project-based rates, meaning you only pay for the time you need.
- No benefits: Say goodbye to expenses like healthcare, retirement contributions, or vacation pay.
- Expertise on demand: Agencies vet Virtual Legal Assistants, saving you the time and cost of training.
Estimated Cost: Agencies charge between $35–$75/hour for a U.S.-based Virtual Legal Assistant, making them a cost-effective choice for small firms.
In-house staff
- Steady overhead: You’ll need office space, equipment, and supplies for them to do their job.
- Full employment package: Budget for fixed salaries, insurance, PTO, and retirement plans.
- Training costs: Invest in initial onboarding and continual professional development.
Estimated Cost: A full-time legal receptionist can cost well over $50,000/year once benefits and overhead are factored in.
What this means for you
Virtual Legal Assistants are incredibly budget-friendly for law firms with limited resources or those looking to scale up without inflating fixed costs. On the other hand, in-house staff makes sense if you need someone in your office consistently.
Scalability and flexibility
Why Virtual Legal Assistants shine
- Adaptability: Sudden increase in casework? VAs easily scale up their hours to accommodate you. Need fewer hours over the summer? Scale back with no strings attached.
- Nation-wide talent pool: Hiring virtually means access to top-notch skills and certifications without geographic limitations.
- Always available: VAs can work different shifts, ensuring coverage across time zones if needed.
What about team members sitting in your office?
- On-site: If you absolutely need someone in the office for daily operations, in-house staff is the clear winner.
- Team dynamics: Being physically present enhances coordination and can improve collaboration with the entire team.
The bottom line? Virtual Legal Assistants offer unparalleled flexibility and scalability, while in-house staff ensure consistent physical presence and face-to-face interactions.
When to hire a Virtual Legal Assistant
Not every task requires someone physically sitting in your office. Here are some situations where a Virtual Legal Assistant is the unsung hero you didn’t know you needed.
- Short-term projects
Need to streamline your filing system? Preparing paperwork for a big case? VAs handle projects like pros without long-term contracts.
- High administrative workload
Emails piling up? Clients complaining about slow responses? Virtual Legal Assistants can swoop in to manage your inbox, calendar, or client communication with ease.
- Specialized expertise
Outsourcing for lawyers often means finding Virtual Legal Assistants with niche skills, such as legal research, content creation for your website, or social media marketing.
- Tight budget
If you’re looking to stretch every dollar, Virtual Legal Assistants help you save on overhead and only charge for hours worked. (So you only pay for the work you need!)
When to hire in-house staff
While Virtual Legal Assistants excel in flexibility, sometimes you just need someone physically in the office. Here are situations where in-house staffing becomes essential.
- Tasks requiring on-site presence
Filing physical legal documents, greeting walk-in clients, and other office-centric tasks can only be handled in person.
- Strict confidentiality needs
For firms with highly sensitive cases where data breaches are a concern, in-house staffing ensures tighter control over confidentiality protocols.
- Long-term relationships
Building a cohesive, collaborative team often benefits from face-to-face interaction. If team dynamics are critical, an in-house member fosters seamless communication.
The verdict
Wishing we could give you a one-size-fits-all solution? We get it. But the truth is, the choice between a Virtual Legal Assistant and in-house staff all boils down to your law firm’s specific needs.
- Choose a Virtual Legal Assistant if you want cost-effective, scalable, and specialized help without geographical limits.
- Choose in-house staff if your tasks require a physical presence or revolve around strict confidentiality.
Managing a law firm is no small feat, but with the right team, you don’t need to go it alone. If you’re ready to experience the ease and efficiency of a Virtual Legal Assistant, Back Office Betties is here to equip your firm with top-tier support tailored to your needs.
Take the first step—schedule a free Discovery Call today and see how our Virtual Legal Assistants can help your firm thrive.
